Queer Eye For The Toxic Guy: Unpacking the Alleged Drama Between the Fab Five

Image via rawpixel

The tenth and final season of Netflix’s reality makeover series Queer Eye aired earlier this week, delivering its trademark emotional uplift alongside a fresh wave of unsettling rumours and behind-the-scenes drama. 

First launched in 2016 as a reboot of Bravo’s Queer Eye For The Straight Guy, the show quickly became a cultural touchstone. Premiering during Trump’s first presidency, it offered comfort and affirmation to many LGBTQ+ viewers and allies amid growing anxiety around queer rights. The five co-hosts (known familiarly as the Fab Five) – Bobby Berk (Design), Karamo Brown (Culture), Tan France (Fashion), Antoni Porowski (Food), and Jonathan Van Ness (Grooming) – modelled diverse queer identities whilst fostering candid conversations about masculinity, sexuality, and self-worth. Much of the show’s feel-good appeal stemmed from the hosts’ seemingly genuine chemistry, marked by banter, affection, and shared vulnerability.

In recent years, however, that image has increasingly fractured. The shift began with Berk’s abrupt departure after season eight, swiftly replaced by interior designer (and France’s close personal friend) Jeremiah Brent. Fans were quick to speculate about internal conflict, as eagle-eyed social media sleuths noticed Berk had unfollowed his fashionista former co-star. The two television personalities separately addressed the rumours, with France claiming "my former colleague getting fired has nothing to do with me trying to get my friend hired”, and Berk later adding "Tan and I had a moment. There was a situation, and that’s between Tan and I, and it has nothing to do with the show [...] We became like siblings – and siblings are always going to fight.” 

Matters escalated further when Rolling Stone published an exposé, alleging serious conflict behind the scenes, including claims from anonymous crew members that Van Ness displayed “rage issues” on set and was “emotionally abusive” towards members of the production team. The article also detailed reported tensions between the five hosts, claiming rivalries had developed over screentime and soundbites, and that their on-screen camaraderie was performative rather than genuine.

This week, tensions resurfaced when Brown declined to attend press events promoting the final season. An email from Brown’s assistant, read aloud on NBC’s Today with Jenna and Sheneille, explained that Brown “has felt mentally and emotionally abused for years, and he has been advised by his therapist to protect himself and his peace by not attending [the scheduled interview].” Brown compensated for his absence with a pre-recorded video, acknowledging his appreciation for fans of the show and the crew, with notably no reference to his co-hosts.

For a series that built its legacy on kindness, vulnerability, and collective joy, these revelations land heavy. Queer Eye changed lives, both for its participants and for viewers who saw themselves reflected on screen. As the curtain falls, it’s hard not to mourn the loss of what the show represented at its best: a reminder that care, connection, and community are not performances, but practices worth protecting.